Sunday, June 12, 2005

I'll probably take this off this blog and put it on struat.com sometime later

I read Daniel Pinkwater's newest book yesterday, The Artsy Smartsy Club. I give it a weary thumbs down, save a few pages toward the end, and a smattering of things here and there.

The problem is that Daniel Pinkwater is taking his position of "single-handedly educating two generations" (paraphrasing something found probably somewhere on the web, I don't know where) a bit... too... much.

I look toward the reviews posted at Amazon, and notice this disagreeable sentence:

Pinkwater has a message to deliver here on the joys of both making and appreciating art, but his conglomeration of eccentric characters and goofy plot twists keep the story from becoming overly didactic.

No they don't.

Okay. That being said... I could try to imagine myself as the "Age 8 to 12" group the book was meant for -- unaware of what happened to Van Gogh's ear or except in an intuitive sense the definition of "didactic", and... I think it would still leave me... cold.

Go ahead and read it... it's redeemable on various levels, and it'd be a quick read. But don't buy it. Buy this one instead.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Links

Progressive Ruin

The Comics Curmudgeon

Oddball Comics

Scott Saavedra

Classic Comic Strips

The Comics Reporter

Cartoonists

Sergio Aargones

David B

Peter Bagge

Carl Barks

Lynda Barry

Vaughn Bode

Brian Bolland

Chester Brown

Ed Brubaker

Eddie Campbell

Del Close

Daniel Clowes

Jack Cole

Johnny Craig

Robert Crumb

Jack Davis

Jennifer Daydreamer

Dan Decarlo

Kim Deitch

Evan Dorkin

Julie Doucet

Dennis Eichhorn

Will Eisner

Bill Elder

Bud Fisher

Renee French

Neil Gaiman

Bill Griffith

Milt Gross

Tom Hart

George Herriman

Ben Katchor

Walt Kelly

Jack Kirby

Bernie Krigstein

Harvey Kurtman

Jon Lewis

Jay Lynch

Larry Marder

Sheldon Mayer

Max

David Mazzuchelli

Winsor McCay

Mike Mignolia

Alan Moore

Josh Nuefeld

Harvey Pekar

John Porcellino

Spain Rodriguez

Scott Saavedra

Joe Sacco

EC Segar

Seth

John Severin

Samm Schwartz

John Stanley

Carol Swain

Cliff Sterrett

Jacques Tardi

Ty Templeton

Bill Watterson

Shannon Wheeler

Basil Wolverton

Wally Wood

Jim Woodring

Aleksandar Zograf